Dr Zakir Naik landed in Pakistan to deliver lectures in major cities, his first visit to the country in the last three decades. He first visited in the early 90s. He is currently living in Malaysia due to controversies and legal troubles caused by the Modi-led government in India.
During his recent visit to Karachi, Pakistan, renowned Islamic scholar and public speaker Dr. Zakir Naik engaged with a large audience, addressing various contemporary issues through an Islamic lens. One of the key topics that gained significant attention during his public talk was his stance on YouTube and earning money through advertisements on the platform. His comments were particularly directed toward content creators, including vloggers, who often use YouTube as a source of income.
In his discussion, Dr. Zakir Naik emphasized that while digital platforms like YouTube offer immense opportunities for reaching audiences, they also present certain ethical concerns for Muslims, particularly regarding monetization through advertisements. His remarks about the presence of inappropriate content in ads, including images of naked women, raised a critical point about the permissibility of earning money through such means in Islam.
For those involved in mobile technology and digital content creation, such as the team at JK Mobiles, Dr. Naik’s comments may offer a fresh perspective on the ethics of using YouTube as a platform for monetization. The JK Mobiles team fully agrees with Dr. Naik’s point about the importance of ensuring that income sources align with Islamic values.
Mobile Devices, YouTube, and Earning Through Ads
In today’s world, mobile devices have become integral to our daily lives. Platforms like YouTube allow millions of users to consume content on various topics, from education and entertainment to product reviews and tutorials. For mobile tech enthusiasts and content creators, YouTube has become an essential tool for sharing valuable insights, such as smartphone reviews, comparisons, and feature breakdowns. Websites like JK Mobiles often rely on such video content to help users understand the specifications and functionality of different mobile devices.
However, as Dr. Naik pointed out, the issue arises when content creators monetize their videos through YouTube ads. While this is a popular method of generating income, Dr. Naik explained that the nature of the ads shown on YouTube could make this form of earning problematic for Muslims.
Dr. Zakir Naik’s Views on YouTube Monetization
During the public talk in Karachi, a vlogger raised a question about earning money through YouTube advertisements. In response, Dr. Naik expressed his concerns, stating that while content creators may be unaware of the specific ads shown during their videos, many of these ads may include haram (forbidden) content, such as images of naked women, girls, or ladies.
He pointed out that the control over what advertisements appear on one’s videos is often limited, as YouTube’s algorithm automatically selects ads based on various factors. Dr. Naik emphasized that if an ad displaying inappropriate content—such as naked women, alcohol, or other haram material—appears before or during a video, the income generated from that ad could be considered impermissible (haram) in Islam.
Why YouTube Earnings May Not Be Halal
Dr. Naik’s main concern revolves around the inadvertent promotion of haram content through ads. He stressed that even if a Muslim content creator’s video itself is halal—such as an Islamic lecture, a mobile phone review, or any other useful content—earning money from ads that show inappropriate content undermines the halal nature of that income.
He explained that content creators might believe they are earning halal money because they are sharing beneficial content, but if ads featuring naked girls or women or promoting haram activities like gambling or alcohol are displayed, the income derived from those ads becomes impermissible.
Dr. Naik specifically mentioned that Muslims must avoid earning through YouTube ads if there is any possibility of such inappropriate content being displayed. He advised that in such cases, Muslims should look for alternative ways to earn income that does not involve promoting or benefiting from haram elements.
Impact on Mobile Tech Creators and Reviewers
For content creators in the mobile tech industry, such as those who contribute to websites like JK Mobiles, Dr. Naik’s perspective on YouTube monetization presents a significant ethical challenge. Many mobile reviewers rely on ad revenue to sustain their channels, as the production costs of high-quality videos, purchasing new devices for reviews, and maintaining equipment can be quite high.
YouTube ads are a major source of income for tech reviewers, who frequently cover the latest mobile phone models, comparing prices and features to help consumers make informed purchasing decisions. However, with Dr. Naik’s remarks in mind, Muslim content creators may need to reconsider their approach to monetization, ensuring that their income aligns with Islamic values.
Alternatives to YouTube Ad Revenue
In light of Dr. Zakir Naik’s guidance, Muslim content creators and mobile reviewers may want to explore alternative ways of earning income that do not involve potentially haram YouTube ads. Some of these alternatives include:
- Sponsored Content: Mobile tech creators can work with smartphone brands or tech companies to create sponsored content. This method allows creators to earn money directly from the company rather than relying on third-party ads. Sponsored content can also ensure that the brand being promoted aligns with Islamic values.
- Affiliate Marketing: Another popular alternative is affiliate marketing, where creators earn commissions by directing their audience to purchase products through specific links. For example, mobile reviewers can include affiliate links to their phone reviews on their channels. This way, they can earn money without relying on potentially inappropriate ads.
- Crowdfunding or Membership Platforms: Platforms like Patreon allow content creators to earn money directly from their audience through donations or memberships. This method eliminates the need for ad-based revenue, giving creators more control over their income sources.
- Merchandise and Digital Products: Tech content creators can also sell branded merchandise or digital products like e-books or exclusive tutorials. This approach not only provides a revenue stream but also builds a stronger connection with the audience.
A Broader Ethical Discussion
Dr. Naik’s comments on YouTube ads and monetization open up a larger discussion about the ethical use of digital platforms. As more Muslims engage in online content creation, e-commerce, and social media, understanding how to navigate these platforms while maintaining Islamic values becomes crucial.
The question of earning halal income is particularly relevant for those involved in the tech world, where mobile phones and other devices are constantly reviewed, compared, and showcased on digital platforms like YouTube. With the increasing reliance on these platforms, content creators must carefully consider how their earnings are generated and whether their income aligns with their religious beliefs.
Conclusion
Dr. Zakir Naik’s visit to Karachi, Pakistan, was met with great enthusiasm, and his public talk covered a range of important topics. His views on YouTube monetization, especially in the context of earning money through ads featuring naked girls or women or other haram content, struck a chord with many Muslim content creators.
For tech creators, including those at JK Mobiles, these comments offer an opportunity to reflect on how they approach monetization. The JK Mobiles team fully agrees with Dr. Naik’s perspective, acknowledging the need to ensure that their income sources are halal.
As the digital landscape continues to evolve, there are numerous ways for content creators to innovate and thrive while ensuring that their income remains halal. For those involved in mobile tech reviews and related fields, this is a crucial consideration.